Saturday, 12 September 2026

Alberta Doesn't Need a Divorce. It Needs Better Leadership.

There is something profoundly exhausting about watching Danielle Smith and the separatist movement turn legitimate frustrations into an endless political theatre production about leaving Canada.

Albertans deserve better than this.

They deserve a government that builds hospitals instead of building enemies. They deserve leadership that creates opportunity instead of manufacturing grievances.  They deserve a premier that understands that being fiercely proud of Alberta does not require being perpetually angry at the rest of the country.

Instead, we have Danielle Smith.

And increasingly, her politics seem less interested in governing Alberta than in keeping Albertans emotionally invested in a never-ending battle with Ottawa, with other provinces, with critics, with journalists, with institutions, and, apparently, with the very idea that cooperation might actually accomplish something.

At some point, someone needs to say:

Danielle Smith has become a divisive cancer on Alberta's political culture.

Not because every policy she supports is wrong.  Not because every criticism of Ottawa isn't legitimate.  And certainly, not because Albertan's don't have legitimate grievances. 

We do.

But there is a massive difference between fighting for Alberta, and constantly convincing Albertans that Alberta is being persecuted.

The first is leadership.

The second is political manipulation.

Alberta is not an island.

The separatist fantasy depends on pretending that Alberta's prosperity exists independently of Canada.

It doesn't.

Our economy doesn't exist in a vacuum.  Our businesses sell to Canadians.  Our workers move freely across provincial borders.  Our banks, transportation networks, infrastructure, pension systems, institutions and supply chains and deeply integrated with the rest of the country.

And Alberta is landlocked.

Our energy wealth has to get to markets through infrastructure, jurisdictions, and trade relationships beyond Alberta's borders.  The idea that becoming a new country somehow makes those realities disappear is not independence.

It's magical thinking.

Even Alberta's business community is warning voters that separation creates enormous uncertainty for jobs, investments, mortgages, trade and the economy.  the Business Council of Alberta has joined other major business organizations in urging Albertans to chose Canada.

That's not Ottawa talking. 

That's Alberta business.

And here's the part that should make every Albertan stop and think.

If Alberta has problems with Ottawa, why is the solution to destroy the relationship instead of fixing it?

We don't burn the house down because we don't like the kitchen.

We renovate it.

We negotiate.

We elect different representatives.

We fight for better deals.

We use Alberta's enormous economic leverage.

We work with other provinces.

We make the federal government understand that Alberta matters.

That is what competent leadership looks like.

Separation is the political equivalent of throwing your cellphone against the wall because you don't like the person you're talking to.

Yes, you feel better for approximately three seconds.

Then you have a broken phone.

Danielle Smith's greatest political accomplishment may be convincing Albertans that anger is a governing strategy.

This is what bothers me most about Smith's politics.

Everything becomes a confrontation.

Everything becomes an Alberta-vs-Ottawa narrative.

Every disagreement becomes an existential threat.

Every federal policy becomes evidence that Canada is somehow fundamentally hostile to Alberta.

And eventually, people stop asking the most important question:

Is this actually making Alberta better.

Because that should be the standard.

Not whether Danielle Smith gets applause at a rally.

Not whether a political base gets fired up.

Not whether another angry social media clip goes viral.

Does it make Alberta better?

Does it make things more affordable?

Does it improve healthcare?

Does it build infrastructure?

Does it attract investments?

Does it create good jobs?

Does it make Alberta place where our children and grandchildren want to stay?

That's the job.

Not endlessly feeding the grievance machine.

And let's be brutally honest about the referendum:

The October vote isn't even a vote on whether or not to leave Canada.  It's a vote about whether or not to proceed toward a future binding referendum on separation.

And yet, Albertans are already being asked to contemplate blowing up a political, economic, and constitutional relationship that has existed for generations.

For what?

To send Ottawa a message?

There are cheaper ways to send a message.

There are smarter ways.

There are considerably less destructive ways.

And if the purpose is leverage, then threatening to leave the country is an extraordinarily expensive bluff.

Because eventually somebody might call it.

Staying in Canada isn't weakness.

This needs to be said loudly because the separatist rhetoric has tried to redefine patriotism.

Choosing Canada does not mean choosing Ottawa over Alberta.

We can be Albertan and Canadian.

In fact, we already are.

I am not embarrassed to be from Alberta.

I am not embarrassed by our oil and gas industry.

I am not embarrassed by our farmers, tradespeople, entrepreneurs, businesses, families, or communities.

I am proud of Alberta.

And precisely because I am proud of Alberta, I don't want to gamble it's future on a political experiment fueled by resentment.

Alberta's future should be bigger than Danielle Smith.

This is ultimately what the separatist movement gets wrong.

Alberta is bigger than one premier.

Bigger than one political party.

Bigger than one grievance.

Bigger than one referendum.

And certainly bigger than Danielle Smith.

We should be building an Alberta that is confident enough to negotiate without constantly threatening divorce.

An Alberta that can disagree with Ottawa without demonizing Canadians in other provinces.

An Alberta that uses its tremendous economic strength to build partnerships rather than walls.

An Alberta that understands that prosperity comes from connection, trade, investment, talent, and cooperation - not isolation.

We don't need to become a smaller country to become a stronger province.

We need better leadership.

We need less political theatre.

We need fewer manufactured enemies.

And we need a premier who understands that being an Albertan does not require hating Canada.

So when the referendum arrives, my answer is simple.

No.

No to the politics of perpetual grievance.

No to turning Alberta against itself.

No to gambling our economic future to satisfy somebody's political fantasy.

No to confusing anger with leadership.

And absolutely no to the idea that Alberta's future is somehow brighter alone.

Alberta doesn't need to leave Canada.

Alberta needs to stop being told that Canada is the enemy.

We don't need a divorce.

We need a government capable of making this marriage work.

If Danielle Smith can't do that, perhaps the questions that Albertans should be asking isn't whether Alberta should leave Canada:

Perhaps it's whether Danielle Smith should leave the premiers office.




No comments:

Post a Comment

America Has Spoken. Now Comes the Hard Part: What the 2026 Midterms Mean for the United States and Canada

There is a message in the results of the 2026 United States midterm elections, and it is one that Donald Trump and the Republican Party woul...