Showing posts with label ICE enforcement. Show all posts
Showing posts with label ICE enforcement. Show all posts

Friday, 9 October 2026

When Immigration Enforcement Becomes a Threat to Human Dignity: The Case for Abolishing ICE

By the time a government agency becomes so powerful that ordinary people fear being mistaken for criminals, families fear being torn apart, and communities fear the people who arrive wearing badges, we should be asking a question that goes far beyond immigration: Who is holding that agency accountable?


There is something profoundly wrong when a country that prides itself on freedom, justice, and the rule of law finds itself debating whether people can be brutalized, detained, separated from their children, or even killed in the name of immigration enforcement.

The United States is supposed to be a country where constitutional rights matter. Where the government is accountable to the people. Where a badge does not grant someone permission to ignore human dignity.

Yet Immigration and Customs Enforcement — ICE — has become the center of a national reckoning over what happens when the machinery of government is allowed to expand faster than the safeguards meant to restrain it.

And it is time to ask the question that makes Washington uncomfortable: What if ICE, as it currently exists, cannot be meaningfully reformed? What if the answer is to abolish the agency and build something fundamentally different?

That is not an argument for open borders. It is not an argument that immigration laws should cease to exist. And it certainly is not an argument that governments have no responsibility to protect public safety.

It is an argument that enforcing the law cannot become an excuse for abandoning the very principles the law is supposed to protect.

This is not merely a debate about political rhetoric or competing ideologies. There are documented reasons to be concerned about the scale, methods, and consequences of American immigration enforcement.

A June 2026 report by Human Rights Watch, drawing on research with Physicians for Human Rights, found that 52 people died in ICE custody between January 20, 2025, and June 4, 2026. Thirty-nine of those deaths occurred during the first year of Donald Trump's second administration, the highest annual total since ICE was established in 2003, according to the report. Researchers also found that the mortality rate had risen disproportionately to the growth in the detained population. 

Read that again.

These are human beings who entered government custody and did not come out alive.

Each number represents someone who had a life beyond an immigration file. Someone who had a family, a history, a voice, and people who may still be waiting for a phone call that will never come.

A death in custody does not, by itself, establish that an individual officer committed a crime or that every death was preventable. But when deaths rise sharply, when detention expands, and when serious questions are raised about medical care and conditions, the government has an obligation to answer those questions transparently.

The answer cannot simply be that immigration enforcement is difficult.

It is difficult. That is precisely why it requires rigorous oversight, professional standards, independent investigations, and meaningful consequences when those standards are violated.

If an agency cannot protect the people in its custody, the public has every right to demand that the system change.

Perhaps one of the most alarming aspects of aggressive immigration enforcement is what happens when the government gets it wrong.

In May 2026, ProPublica reported that Leonardo Garcia Venegas, a U.S. citizen, had been detained by immigration agents for a third time. In an earlier incident, he had been tackled while filming his brother's arrest at an Alabama construction site. ProPublica also reported the case of an American teenager who was tackled by masked agents, left injured, and later found to be a citizen. 

In September 2026, the Associated Press reported that a U.S. citizen in Evanston, Illinois, suffered injuries to his head, neck, and teeth after immigration agents mistakenly identified him as a fugitive they were seeking. The local police department investigated the encounter. 

These cases raise a question that should concern every American, regardless of political affiliation: What happens when the government decides you look like someone it wants to arrest?

Citizenship is supposed to mean something. Constitutional protections are not supposed to depend on a person's appearance, accent, surname, or ability to produce identification quickly enough to satisfy an armed officer.

Mistaken arrests can happen in any law-enforcement system. But repeated reports of citizens being detained, injured, or misidentified demand more than assurances that mistakes are rare or regrettable.

They demand accountability.

And when people are afraid to record an arrest, question an officer, accompany a family member, or go about their daily lives because they fear being caught up in an enforcement operation, the damage extends far beyond the person who is arrested.

It changes how an entire community experiences the government.

The debate over ICE is often reduced to a familiar political slogan: deport the dangerous criminals.

Protecting the public from people who pose genuine threats is a legitimate government responsibility. But the reality of immigration enforcement is more complicated than that slogan suggests.

Human Rights Watch reported in June 2026 that, as of April, fewer than 18,000 of more than 60,000 people in ICE detention had a prior U.S. criminal conviction. Approximately 24,000 had neither a prior conviction nor pending criminal charges. These figures describe criminal records and charges in the United States; they do not establish that every detained person had no immigration violation or posed no conceivable risk. They do, however, challenge the idea that the detention system consists exclusively of people with criminal convictions.

The distinction matters.

An immigration violation is not the same thing as a violent crime. A person who has lived peacefully in a community for decades, raised children, worked, and contributed to society should not automatically be treated as though they present the same public-safety risk as someone convicted of a serious violent offence.

That does not mean immigration law should be ignored. It means enforcement priorities should be proportionate, evidence-based, and subject to due process.

There is also a practical consideration: when immigration officers operate in ways that make entire communities afraid of government institutions, people may become reluctant to report crimes, cooperate with investigations, or seek assistance when they are in danger.

Public safety depends on trust. Trust is difficult to maintain when people believe that contacting authorities could expose them or their loved ones to detention.

A system designed to make communities safer should not needlessly undermine the relationships that help keep those communities safe.

The violence cannot simply be dismissed

In July 2026, The Washington Post published an analysis identifying at least 17 motorists who had been shot during federal immigration operations since the beginning of Trump's second term. Six people, including two U.S. citizens, had died in those shootings, according to the newspaper's reporting at that time. 

Then, on October 8, 2026, ICE agents shot and injured a man inside his vehicle in New York City while his five-year-old child was present. The child was unharmed. Federal authorities said the agents were conducting a targeted operation to arrest a Dominican Republic national with a criminal history. The circumstances and justification for the shooting require careful investigation. 

These incidents must be assessed individually. An officer's use of force may be justified in some circumstances, and the available reports alone do not establish that every shooting was unlawful.

But the frequency of these encounters raises a larger question: What kind of enforcement strategy are Americans being asked to accept, and what safeguards ensure that force is necessary, proportionate, and independently scrutinized?

An immigration arrest should not become a death sentence. A traffic encounter should not become a shooting without a thorough examination of what happened. And the presence of a child should remind every adult involved that the consequences of a violent encounter can last long after the immediate operation ends.

The public deserves transparent investigations, accessible evidence where legally appropriate, and consequences when misconduct is established.

Accountability is not an attack on law enforcement. It is one of the conditions that makes legitimate law enforcement possible.

There is another question that deserves far more scrutiny: Why is so much public money being committed to an expanding detention system, and who is responsible for ensuring that money is spent properly?

In September 2026, the Department of Homeland Security's Office of Inspector General reported that ICE had not always adequately planned, procured, or monitored detention-space contracts and agreements worth almost $10 billion during fiscal years 2020 through 2023. The watchdog identified weaknesses in forecasting detention needs and overseeing contracts. The report also noted that ICE had since received $45 billion for detention space, making stronger oversight especially important. 

Separately, a June 2026 Government Accountability Office report found that Camp East Montana, ICE's largest detention facility, was opened quickly and faced significant operational problems. Its contract required payment for meals and services for 5,000 people even when the population was much lower. The facility also failed to meet key detention standards, according to the GAO.

These findings are about more than accounting.

They raise questions about whether the government is building a detention system before adequately establishing its needs, whether contracts are being monitored effectively, and whether the public is receiving value for the money it spends.

When billions of dollars flow into detention, the public should expect rigorous scrutiny of every contract, every facility, and every claim that more detention is necessary.

Money spent on poorly monitored detention is money that cannot be used elsewhere. And when people are held in facilities that fail to meet essential standards, the consequences are not merely financial.

They are human.

The question is not whether every dollar spent on detention is wasted or whether every private contractor acts improperly. The evidence does not support such sweeping claims. The question is whether a system built around expanding detention has adequate incentives and safeguards to ensure that human welfare, rather than bed capacity and enforcement targets, remains central to decision-making.

That question deserves a serious answer.

So why abolish ICE?

Abolishing ICE does not have to mean abolishing immigration enforcement.

It means recognizing that an agency's existing structure is not sacred simply because it exists. Government institutions are created to serve the public. When their structure, incentives, and practices repeatedly produce serious concerns about civil liberties, accountability, and human welfare, restructuring must be a legitimate option.

The case for abolition is that piecemeal reform may not be enough if the problems are rooted in the way the institution operates.

Abolition advocates can reasonably argue that immigration enforcement should be rebuilt around a narrower, more transparent mandate, with stronger protections for people in custody and more meaningful limits on coercive power.

A replacement system could include:

  • Independent oversight: Investigations of deaths, serious injuries, and alleged misconduct conducted by genuinely independent bodies, with public reporting and enforceable recommendations.
  • Due process protections: Clear procedures for challenging detention, meaningful access to lawyers, timely hearings, and effective remedies when people are wrongly detained.
  • Alternatives to detention: Community-based supervision and other less restrictive options when detention is unnecessary to address a demonstrated risk.
  • Strict limits on force: Clear rules governing arrests, vehicle encounters, identification, warrants, and the use of weapons, supported by independent review.
  • Transparent spending: Public disclosure and rigorous audits of detention contracts, facility conditions, medical care, and enforcement outcomes.
  • Targeted public-safety priorities: Decisions grounded in individual circumstances and credible evidence of risk, rather than a system that treats immigration status itself as a sufficient reason for unnecessarily harsh treatment.

Some functions could be transferred to other agencies; others could be placed in a newly structured immigration service. Any transition would need to preserve essential functions, protect employees' legal rights, and ensure that immigration cases continue to receive lawful and timely consideration.

Abolition should not be an empty slogan followed by the recreation of the same problems under a different name.

If the United States chooses this path, it must dismantle the practices that produced the failures, not simply change the sign on the building.

And the public should judge the replacement by measurable outcomes: fewer preventable deaths, fewer wrongful detentions, effective legal remedies, safer communities, responsible spending, and greater transparency.

This is about what America wants to be

There is a temptation to treat immigration as a problem that can be solved through displays of force. To imagine that more arrests, more detention beds, more raids, and more aggressive enforcement will automatically produce a safer, stronger country.

But a government does not prove its strength by demonstrating how many people it can detain.

It proves its strength by demonstrating that its power has limits.

It proves its commitment to justice by allowing scrutiny, correcting mistakes, and refusing to treat human beings as disposable when the machinery of government gets it wrong.

And it proves its commitment to public safety by distinguishing genuine threats from people whose circumstances require a different response.

None of this requires pretending that immigration policy has easy answers. Countries have legitimate interests in managing their borders, administering immigration laws, and protecting their residents. People disagree, sometimes profoundly, about how those responsibilities should be balanced.

But there should be no disagreement about the need for accountability when people die in custody, citizens are wrongly detained, force is used, or detention facilities fail to meet essential standards.

Those are not partisan questions. They are questions about the responsibilities that accompany state power.

The people who enter immigration detention do not lose their humanity. The people who are wrongly identified do not lose their rights. And the families left grieving after a death in custody do not lose their right to answers simply because their loved one was an immigrant.

If ICE cannot carry out its mission without repeated, serious failures of accountability and human welfare, then the United States must be prepared to consider replacing it with a system designed from the ground up to do better.

That is what abolition should mean: not abandoning the rule of law, but refusing to accept an institution's failures as the price of enforcing it.

The question is not whether America has the right to enforce its immigration laws. The question is whether it can do so without sacrificing the principles it claims to defend.

A government that demands obedience from the people must also be willing to answer to them.

And when the cost of enforcement is measured in human lives, shattered families, injured citizens, and billions of dollars spent without adequate oversight, asking whether the institution itself should continue to exist is not an unreasonable question.

It is a question democracy requires us to ask.

America Has Spoken. Now Comes the Hard Part: What the 2026 Midterms Mean for the United States and Canada

There is a message in the results of the 2026 United States midterm elections, and it is one that Donald Trump and the Republican Party woul...