Showing posts with label Edmonton Oilers Controversy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Edmonton Oilers Controversy. Show all posts

Friday, 11 September 2026

I'm Done Cheering for the Edmonton Oilers

There are moments when being a sports fan stops being about hockey.

Yesterday was one of those moments.

The Edmonton Oilers signed Alex Formenton to a one-year $850,000 contract. And with that decision, the organization crossed a line I can no longer ignore.

So, I am done.

I will not cheer for the Edmonton Oilers while Alex Formenton wears an Oilers jersey.

And I don't say that lightly.

For years, being an Oilers fan has meant something to me. It meant community. It meant family. It meant gathering around the television, wearing the jersey, believing that maybe - just maybe- this would be the year.

It means Wayne Gretzky. It means Connor McDavid. It means playoff heartbreak. It means Stanley Cup dreams and wins. It means being proud to call this team ours.

But there are some things that should matter more than hockey.

The dignity of victims matters more.

The organization has chosen to employ a player who was one of five former members of Canada's 2018 World Junior team accused in connection with a sexual assault case. All five were acquitted at trial. That legal outcome matters, and nobody should pretend otherwise. But an acquittal is not a declaration that nothing troubling happened. In fact, the NHL itself has acknowledged that the conduct surrounding the case was deeply troubling and unacceptable and said that it failed to meet the league's standard of moral integrity.

That distinction seems to have disappeared somewhere between the courtroom and the Oiler's front office.

Because apparently the question has become:

"Can he legally play hockey?"

Instead, I believe the question should be:

"Should we want someone connected to this case representing our organization, our city, our children and our sport?"

My answer is no.

And before anyone tells me that this is simply about an acquittal, let me be very clear: I am not claiming that Formenton was found guilty in criminal court. He wasn't.

I am saying that an NHL team has a choice.

The Oilers didn't have to sign him.

They weren't forced to put an $850,000 contract in front of him. They didn't have to decide that whatever concerns remained were outweighed by what he could contribute on the ice.

They chose to.

That is what I find so profoundly disturbing.

This wasn't inevitable. It was a business decision.

And businesses communicate with their values through the decisions they make.

The message I hear from this decision is that once the legal consequences are over, the rest can be forgotten.

That a player can step back on the ice, put on the jersey, collect the paycheque and carry on as though none of it happened.

But, for victims of sexual violence, it doesn't work that wya.

There is no final buzzer.

There is no clean sheet of ice.

There is no convenient offseason in which the memories disappear.

And when professional sports organizations welcome players back without acknowledging the profound harm and mistrust surrounding these cases, they risk sending an incredibly damaging message:

Your pain has an expiration date. Our entertainment doesn't

I cannot accept that.

I also believe the NHL needs to take a much harder look at its own standards. If the league says conduct can be so troubling and unacceptable that it fails its own standard of moral integrity, then what exactly does "moral integrity" mean if those same players can eventually return to the league and be celebrated as professional athletes?

What does accountability actually mean?

Because right now, it feels like accountability ends the moment the public attention dies down.

And that is unacceptable.

I believe the players involved in this case should never again be given the privilege of representing the NHL

Not because I believe an acquittal should be ignored.

Not because I believe accusations should automatically equal criminal guilt.

But because professional sports organizations have the right - and, in my opinion, the responsibility - to establish standards that are higher than the bare minimum required by law.

The NHL is not a courtroom.

An NHL contract is not a constitutional right.

And playing professional hockey isn't something society owes anyone.

These organizations chose whom they employ. They choose whom they put on television. They chose whose name goes on jerseys. They choose whom children are encouraged to admire.

Those choices should reflect more than talent, speed, goals and points.

They should reflect character.

The Oilers had an opportunity to say: There are lines that we will not cross.

Instead, they said, in effect: He can play hockey, so we'll give him a contract.

For me, that is enough.

I am not going to pretend everything is fine because the Oilers are winning.

I am not going to cheer because the puck goes into the net.

I am not going to buy the jersey.

I am not going to rationalize it because "everyone deserves a second chance."

There are countless hockey players in the world. The Oilers had options.

They chose this one.

And I get to make my own choice.

My choice is to walk away.

I will not abandon my values to remain loyal to a hockey team.

I will not tell survivors that their pain matters while simultaneously cheering for an organization that I believe has made a decision profoundly disrespectful to them.

And I certainly will not teach the next generation that winning is important enough to make us look the other way something deeply troubling happens.

Hockey supposed to be a game.

It is not supposed to be an excuse for us to suspend our conscience.

So, Edmonton Oilers, enjoy the $850,000 hockey player.

You've made your choice.

I've made mine.

I will still love hockey.

I will still love Edmonton.

I will still remember the incredible moments this team has given me.

But I will no longer cheer for the Edmonton Oilers while Alex Formenton is wearing that jersey.

Because some things are bigger than hockey.

Victims matter. Accountability matters. Character matters.

And no Stanley Cup is worth compromising those things.








America Has Spoken. Now Comes the Hard Part: What the 2026 Midterms Mean for the United States and Canada

There is a message in the results of the 2026 United States midterm elections, and it is one that Donald Trump and the Republican Party woul...